Find out whether your invention is ready to file.
TIPScore™ reviews an invention disclosure against U.S., European and Chinese patent law. You get a readiness score from 0 to 100 and a list of what to fix first. It was built by Torrey Pines Consulting.
Sample report
Illustrative figures. The six scoring dimensions:
- D1: Inventive content
- D2: § 101 eligibility
- D3: Inverted bar risk
- D4: § 112 enablement
- D5: Ownership and Bayh-Dole
- D6: Commercial value
Europe and China are screened separately and reported as bands, not averaged into the U.S. score.
How the audit works
Every disclosure goes through the same four stages in order. A fatal bar found in an early stage cannot be hidden by a good score later.
- Priority and filing dates. We work out the effective filing date in the U.S., Europe and China, and check provisional chains for new matter the provisional does not support. Paris Convention; 35 U.S.C. § 119(e)
- Statutory dealbreakers. We look for on-sale activity, public preprints, open-source commits and third-party disclosures that can end your rights before you file. Helsinn; 35 U.S.C. § 102; EPC Art. 54
- Conditional recoveries. If a bar turns up, we test whether it can be salvaged through experimental use, breach of confidence or a method-of-use carve-out. Pfaff; EPC Art. 55
- Patent Readiness Score. Whatever survives is scored across six legal dimensions. The result comes with a ranked list of fixes. Dimensions D1 through D6
The same sale can be recoverable in the U.S. and fatal in Europe.
United States
Under Pfaff and City of Elizabeth, a transaction made mainly to test the invention can count as experimental use, which keeps your U.S. rights intact.
Europe and China
Neither EPC Articles 54 and 55 nor Article 24 of the PRC Patent Law has an experimental sales exception. Those rights are lost, and TIPScore shows the region as red with the reason.
What the score means
Every deduction in a report cites the statute or case behind it. If a critical requirement fails, such as an unsalvaged on-sale bar or an AI named as the only inventor, the score is capped at 40 however strong the rest of the disclosure is.
- 85–100, Exceptional: Clear to file a non-provisional application.
- 70–84, Strong: Sound. Minor cleanup recommended.
- 50–69, Moderate risk: Strengthen with a provisional filing first.
- 0–49, Critical block: Hold filing until the problems are fixed.
If you are an inventor
Fill in one guided disclosure form. It has sections for digital and AI, life sciences, mechanical, and physics and energy inventions. You get a plain-language result showing where you stand and what to add, before a conversation or a sale puts your rights at risk.
If you are an attorney
Triage incoming disclosures the same way every time. Each finding ties back to a statute, a case and a firm drafting rule you can point to. If the AI service is unavailable, a deterministic engine keeps scoring running.
The firm’s drafting rules
Torrey Pines applies sixteen drafting rules to every disclosure. Six of them are below, and the rest appear in your report.
- Rule 01, Exhaustive antecedent basis (35 U.S.C. § 112(b)): Every claim term is introduced clearly and appears verbatim in the specification.
- Rule 03, No subjective terms in independent claims (Akamai; Datamize): Words like "substantially" and "optimal" need a measurable tolerance or a standard test behind them.
- Rule 05, Defend against bars in every jurisdiction (Helsinn; EPC Art. 54): The priority filing comes before any commercial exposure, NDA or not.
- Rule 08, Anchor claims to a technical improvement (Recentive; Alice Step 2B): Software claims must improve how a computer works, not describe a business result.
- Rule 10, Disclose parameters in three tiers (35 U.S.C. § 112(a)): Each number appears as a broad range, a preferred range and a best-mode value.
- Rule 12, Draft each claim for a single actor (Akamai multi-actor doctrine): One party should be able to infringe on its own, so divided infringement is never required.
The law behind the score
These are the decisions TIPScore relies on most. Each one shows up in reports as the reason for a deduction or a recommendation.
- Helsinn v. Teva (139 S. Ct. 594): A confidential sale still triggers the on-sale bar. A signed supply contract can end patentability.
- Pfaff v. Wells Electronics (525 U.S. 55): Defines when an invention is on sale, and when genuine testing preserves U.S. rights.
- Recentive v. Fox Sports (Fed. Cir. 2024): Applying generic machine learning to a business goal is an abstract idea under § 101.
- Amgen v. Sanofi (143 S. Ct. 1243): A broad functional genus must be enabled across its full scope.
- Thaler v. Vidal (Fed. Cir. 2022): Only a natural person can be an inventor, so human conception has to be documented.
Frequently asked questions
What is TIPScore™?
TIPScore™ is a patent readiness screening tool built by Torrey Pines Consulting. It reviews an invention disclosure against U.S., European and Chinese patent law and returns a readiness score from 0 to 100 with a ranked list of what to fix before you file.
What does the score measure?
The score covers six legal dimensions: inventive content, Section 101 eligibility, inverted bar risk, Section 112 enablement, ownership and Bayh-Dole, and commercial value. Before scoring, TIPScore checks filing dates and statutory bars such as on-sale activity and public disclosures.
How do I read my score?
A score of 85 to 100 is exceptional and clear to file a non-provisional application. 70 to 84 is strong, with minor cleanup recommended. 50 to 69 is moderate risk, so strengthen the case with a provisional filing first. 0 to 49 is a critical block: hold filing until the problems are fixed.
Can TIPScore tell me if I have already lost my patent rights?
It looks for the usual causes: on-sale activity, public preprints, open-source commits and third-party disclosures that can end your rights before you file. If it finds one, it tests whether the problem can be recovered, for example through experimental use or breach of confidence.
Does TIPScore replace a patent attorney?
No. It is a screening tool that shows where a disclosure is weak, so that you and your attorney spend time on the right problems. It does not give legal advice or guarantee that a patent will be granted.
Is my invention disclosure kept confidential?
Each law firm’s cases are stored in that firm’s own separate database, and the contents of disclosures are encrypted in storage. Only people the firm has approved can sign in. To analyze a disclosure, its text is sent to Google’s Gemini AI service on a paid plan. Under Google’s paid-service terms, Google does not use that content to improve its products; it may keep logs for a limited time to detect abuse.
Who can use TIPScore, and how do I get an account?
TIPScore is provided through law firms, including Torrey Pines Law Group®. You request an account, and an administrator at the firm approves it and chooses what you can do.
Who is behind TIPScore
TIPScore is built by Torrey Pines Consulting and applies the drafting rules and legal logic of Torrey Pines Law Group®, an intellectual property law firm founded in San Diego in 2013.
- Kevin Buckley, J.D., Founder & Managing Shareholder, Registered Patent Attorney. Founded Torrey Pines Law Group in 2013. Advises AI and life sciences companies and their investors on patents, transactions, FDA regulation and IP disputes. J.D., University of Pittsburgh School of Law; B.S., University of California, San Diego.
- Stephen Giang, AI Engineer. Builds automation and AI systems for the firm, including LLM-based document workflows. B.S. in Applied Mathematics, San Diego State University, Magna Cum Laude.
- Milan Shah, Patent Engineer. Supports the firm’s IP practice with patent preparation and prosecution for LLM, machine-learning and neural-network technologies, from the Irvine and Los Angeles offices.
Last updated November 20, 2026
Check your disclosure before you file.
It is much cheaper to find a problem now than during prosecution.